Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission if you click a link and purchase something. Please check out my disclosure policy for more details. All opinions are my own!

---

The Best Easter Basket Ideas for Newborns—No Candy Needed!

I remember celebrating my first Easter as a new mom—running on coffee, soaking up baby snuggles, and still wanting to make the day feel special. If this is your baby’s first Easter, you might be wondering what to put in a basket for a newborn.

Let’s be real—your little one won’t remember it, but you will. And there’s just something sweet about marking this first holiday with a few thoughtful, practical, and meaningful gifts.

Related:

• 13+ Fun Easter Basket Themes Your Kids Will LOVE
• The Best Easter Dresses for Nursing Moms
• 55+ More Easter Ideas for Littles (that aren’t candy)

---

First Things First—The Easter Basket

If you don’t already have an Easter basket, now is the perfect time to get one you’ll love pulling out year after year.

You can grab a simple one from Target or Amazon, but if you want something extra special, check out personalized baskets on Etsy. They’re adorable, high-quality, and make for the cutest keepsakes.

This one has my heart right now—I may or may not have just hit “add to cart.”

---

Easter Basket Fillers for Newborns

Since newborns don’t need candy (or even toys just yet), focus on items that are useful, comforting, and sentimental. Here are some great ideas:

Soft & Snuggly

• Plush Bunny or Lamb – A sweet little stuffed animal makes a perfect first Easter gift.
• Swaddle Blanket – A soft, cozy blanket is always a good idea. Bonus points if it has an Easter theme or these sweet neutral greens.
• Lovey – If your baby is old enough for one, a small security blanket can be a wonderful comfort item.
• Easter Jammies or Outfit – Because is there anything cuter than a baby in a festive onesie? I love how cute this one is!

Practical & Useful

• Teethers – Fun shapes like a bunny or carrot are adorable and functional.
• Bandana Bibs – Cute, practical, and perfect for catching all that newborn drool.
• Pacifiers & Clips – If your baby uses them, this is a great time to refresh your stash. (we love these ones!)
• Nose Frida – Not the most exciting gift, but definitely one of the most useful!

Books & Keepsakes

• Board Books or Soft Crinkle Books – “Guess How Much I Love You” or an Easter-themed book makes for a sweet tradition.
• Baby’s First Easter Keepsake – A special ornament, photo frame, or milestone card to remember the day. I love this one!
• Growth Chart – Start tracking those precious little inches with a cute, personalized chart.

---

Making Easter Special for You & Baby

Your newborn won’t remember this Easter, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t worth celebrating. Take some photos, soak up the moments, and enjoy this season with your little one.

Did you do an Easter basket for your newborn? I’d love to hear what you included!

✅ More Mom-Approved Baby Easter Basket Stuffers

Here’s a quick list of some of the top Easter basket stuffers for baby’s first Easter and even things your toddler will LOVE. The full list is below!